PATTERNS OF EVIDENCE: THE MOSES CONTROVERSY

Directed by
TIMOTHY P. MAHONEY

Executive Producer
DAVID WESSNER

Produced by
TIMOTHY P. MAHONEY
DIANE WALKER

Written by
TIMOTHY P. MAHONEY
STEVEN LAW

Edited by
CHAD S. GREENE

FEATURED INTERVIEWS

In order of appearance

TIMOTHY P. MAHONEY
Investigative Filmmaker, Author

RANDALL PRICE
Co-director, Qumran Cave Excavation Project

WILLIAM DEVER
Archaeologist, Professor Emeritus – University of Arizona

DONALD REDFORD
Egyptologist – Penn State University

DOUGLAS KNIGHT
Professor Emeritus of Hebrew Bible – Vanderbilt Divinity School

PETER J. GENTRY
Professor of Old Testament Interpretation – Southern Baptist Theological Seminary

JODI MAGNESS
Distinguished Professor of Early Judaism – University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

DUANE GARRETT
Professor of Old Testament Interpretation – Southern Baptist Theological Seminary

DAVID ROHL
Egyptologist, Author ‘Exodus – Myth or History?’

BRIAN RICKETT
Principal Researcher – MIKRA Research Laboratory

CHRISTOPHER ROLLSTON
Professor of Northwest Semitic Languages – George Washington University

RABBI MANIS FRIEDMAN
Biblical Scholar, Author

OS GUINNESS
Social Critic, Author

CHRIS NAUNTON
President – International Association of Egyptologists

ORLY GOLDWASSER
Professor of Egyptology – The Hebrew University

DOUGLAS PETROVICH
Professor of Biblical History and Exegesis – The Bible Seminary

RABBI MICHAEL SHELOMO BAR-RON
Torah Scholar, Author

NABIL KONI
as Moses

WRITTEN BY:
Timothy P. Mahoney
Steven Law

EDITED BY:
Chad S. Greene
Timothy P. Mahoney

ASSOCIATE PRODUCER:
Jared Neher

DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY:
Timothy P. Mahoney

AUDIO POST PRODUCTION SERVICES PROVIDED BY:
Undertone Music – Minneapolis, MN:
Supervising Sound Editor & Re-recording Mixer – Tom Hambleton CAS
Sound Editors – Avry Luy, Ian McClintock

ON-LINE EDITOR:
Chad S. Greene

ADDITIONAL EDITORS:
Matthew Pankratz
Jared Neher

ASSISTANT EDITOR:
Ryan Swan

MEDIA MANAGERS:
Ryan Swan
Jack Sutter

WRITING & CONTENT ADVISORS:
David Rohl
Clinton Ohlers
Dr. Scott Stripling
Matthew Keller

CREATIVE CONSULTANT:
Kevin O’Neill

VISUAL EFFECTS:
Matthew Pankratz

3D ANIMATIONS & VISUAL EFFECTS:
Vandegrift Renderings:
Dorian Vandegrift – animation supervisor
Clarence Olsen – technical specialist
Ulco Glimmerveen – background artist
Gideon Vandegrift, Doug Vandegrift

Reel Inspirations:
Jim Huenergardt

MAP ANIMATIONS:
Peter Wagner
Jack Sutter

2D ANIMATIONS & GRAPHICS:
Chad S. Greene
Matthew Pankratz
Jared Neher
Jack Sutter

ADDITIONAL ANIMATION:
Ben Pierre

STORYBOARDS & ILLUSTRATIONS:
Matthew Keller

TITLE SEQUENCE & TEXT ELEMENT DESIGN:
Kevin O’Neill
Chad S. Greene

COLORIST:
Jared Neher

PRODUCTION

USA

REENACTMENT CAST:
Girl Reading – Lola Mae Mahoney
Solomon – Thomas Ramy
Tabernacle/Ark Builder – Gerald Pierre
High Priest – Pete Windahl

CHARACTER VOICES:
Alan Johnson – Eupolemus
Cristobal Krusen – Joseph Naveh, Flinders Petrie

Passover Scene:
Craig Aizman
Aarah Aizman
Ian Aizman
Chana Aizman
Sara Aizman
Marilyn Goldman
Wendy Berezovsky
Mike Berezovsky
Reuven Berezovsky
Eliana Berezovsky
Chaya Dalya Berezovsky

REENACTMENT PRODUCER:
Kim Dulas
Timothy P. Mahoney

CINEMATOGRAPHERS:
Timothy P. Mahoney
John Burch

CAMERA OPERATORS:
Chris Rodgers
Nicole Will
Jill Mahoney

LOCATION SOUND:
Jill Mahoney

GAFFERS:
Joe Birr
Todd Nielson

STILL PHOTOGRAPHY:
Matthew Pankratz
Timothy P. Mahoney

PRODUCTION ASSISTANTS:
Kim Dulas
Jill Mahoney
Nicole Will

PRODUCTION CREW:
Matthew Pankratz
Steve Law

PROPS & COSTUMES:
Alan Johnson
Guthrie Theater
Grace Church – Dara Mann

STUDIO:
Mahoney Media

LOCATION SOUND RECORDING:
Jill Mahoney
Michael R. Severson

MAKEUP ARTISTS:
Tessie Bundick
Sara Haymaker

SPECIAL THANKS TO
University of Pittsburgh Heinz Memorial Chapel
Chabad-Lubavitch House, St. Paul
James J. Hill House
James J. Hill Library

EGYPT

REENACTMENT CAST:
Abraham Lehali – Joseph
Salah Abu Sina – Jacob
Jaol Noovaldeeen Jaber – Young Moses
Gmaan Farah – Old Moses
Odeh Mohamed Hassan Jhalin – Ipuwer
Omar Jhahalin – Egyptian taskmaster
Mohamed Abu Dhahoh
Yusef Jhahalil
Yusef Abu Dhahoh
Mickey Rifiac
Sahbed Ahmad Mohamed
Ahmed Ahmed Jhalin
Abdu Ahmad
Chalil Company actors

EGYPT PRODUCTION SERVICES:
Egypt Fixer Productions
The Film Maker Company

LINE PRODUCERS:
Rick Garside
Ramy Romany

TECHNICAL ADVISOR:
David Rohl

CINEMATOGRAPHERS:
Ramy Romany
Jack Tankard
Timothy P. Mahoney

CAMERA OPERATORS:
Aaron Sen
Ross Patterson
Andrew Ross
Ditas Rohl

LOCATION SOUND RECORDING:
Greg Hill
David Wessner

STILL PHOTOGRAPHY:
Timothy P. Mahoney
Ramy Romany
David Rohl
Ditas Rohl

BOAT OPERATORS:
Moustafa Roshdi
Sobhi Mohamed

ISRAEL

ISRAEL PRODUCTION COORDINATION:
Biblical Productions:
Sharon Schaveet
Esty Altshul
Chalil Company
Thinking Man Films
Peter Windahl

CINEMATOGRAPHERS:
Timothy P. Mahoney
Miles Hanon
Yoram Millo
Sebastian Hanstein

CAMERA OPERATORS:
Ayman Abu Abu Ramouz
Jill Mahoney
Martin Severin

DRONE FOOTAGE:
Worthington Media Services

LOCATION SOUND RECORDING:
Simson Yanai
Jill Mahoney

PRODUCTION ASSISTANTS:
Jill Mahoney
Martin Severin

JEEPS:
Haim Berger

STILL PHOTOGRAPHY:
Pierre Terdjman
Jill Mahoney
Martin Severin

SPECIAL THANKS TO:
Israel Museum
Shrine of the Book
W. F. Albright Institute of Archaeological Research
The Megiddo Expedition and Excavators

EUROPE

CHARACTER VOICES:
Nicholas Brown – Alan Gardiner

CINEMATOGRAPHY:
Timothy P. Mahoney
Crawford Teller
Isaac Will
Sebastian Hanstein
Miles Hanon

PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT:
Malcolm Turner, CTA
Martin Severin – Germany, Austria

PRODUCTION SERVICES:
Sparks Productions
Jonathan Sheard
Stephen Briggs

STILL PHOTOGRAPHY:
Jill Mahoney
Timothy P. Mahoney
Isaac Will
Nicole Will

SPECIAL THANKS TO
Luxor Museum
British Museum
The Griffith Institute, Oxford University
The Petrie Museum of Egyptian Archaeology

JORDAN

REENACTMENT CAST
Joshua – Mahmoud Hammad
Flinders Petrie – Ahmad Shaman
Hilda Peterie – Rasha Abu Rsheid
Aaron – Shant Hambroom
Benny / Jethro – Haidar Qaraein

Israelite Extras in the Wilderness:
Mahmoud Khaled Mashallah
Samiah Shamisine
Ahmed Ahmened Ahmed
Hamid Ahmed Asri
Nour Ahmed Abulayis
Mohamad Issmian Mashallah
Ayhan Mohammed Mashallah
Sadddam Al Mashallah
Ahmed Wauiar Massadah
Amjad Mashallah
Hamsa Dafallah Mashallah
Abdullah Mashallah
Abdullah Mohammed Al Mashallah
Alla Ahmed Asri
Ryan Alus Mose
Syim Mashallah
Saylam Khaled Samkire
Mohammed Kharem Falihat
Khaled Al Mashallah
Mosab Mohammad Al Mosada
Sami Massadah
Abdullah Soyman Amerine
Abed Ahmed Asri
Saylam Al Bedul
Rajjah Ali Alganinate
Hosam Mashalah
Obada Mohammed Nowaflah
Nashat Abdullah Mashalah
Loyah Falahate
Zaid Al Masada
Khalid Mashallah
Sylaman Abdullah Amerine
Sabri Mashallah
Rabiya Juma Al Bedul
Yousef Osama Al Ayine
All Mosabi Al Mashallah
Mustafa Osama Al Ayine
Marwah Ahyed Ahmed
Osama Al Amie
Rawan Samahin
Rahaf Al Bedul
Hana Mutlag Adjmadi
Rawan Samahin
Hana Ali Ajdilate
Hoha Khalil Samahine
Hanan Drabijah Ajdilate
Wafa Khalil Samahine
Bahtul Khalil Samahine
Hind Al Samahine
Eraddah Salyaman
Hassina Al Bedul Samahine
Hallah Slyman Ajdeiaht
Sabbah Slyman Ajdelate
Sabbah Al Wayman
Miriam Mohammed
Sarah Ali Ajdilate
Anout Al Faqueer
Ameal Al Samahine
Rohiyah Rahan Al Samahine
Sajadah Yaya Al Mowasa
Najdan Al Samahine
Fousia Ajdilate
Fatimeh Ali Adjmadi

PRODUCER:
Ghassan Salti
Timothy P. Mahoney

PRODUCTION ASSISTANT:
Mustafa Masadeh
Martin Severin

PRODUCTION COORDINATOR;
Hosny Mayoof

DRONE OPERATORS:
Martin Severin
Sami Kattan

CINEMATOGRAPHERS:
Sami Kattan
Timothy P. Mahoney
Sebastian Hanstein
Isaac Will
Miles Hanon

CAMERA OPERATORS:
Martin Severin

LOCATION SOUND RECORDING:
Jill Mahoney
Michael R. Severson

STILL PHOTOGRAPHY:
Timothy P. Mahoney
Angelica Moller
Isaac Will

SPECIAL THANKS:
Royal Film Commission- Jordan
Jordan Department of Antiquities

SAUDI ARABIA

DiscoveredSinai.com
Andrew Jones
Nathan Bange
Adam Oliver
Jim and Penny Caldwell

MUSIC

ORIGINAL MUSIC BY:
Jonathan David Neal
Rob Barrett
David Rohl

BUDAPEST MUSIC
ORCHESTRA, CHOIR & ETHNIC MUSIC:
Concert and Media KFT
Studio 22, Budapest, Hungary

BUDAPEST FILM ORCHESTRA

CONCERTMASTER:
Mr. Gábor Bohus

SYMPHONY CONDUCTOR:
Jonathan David Neal

MUSIC COORDINATOR:
Mr. Csaba Lokös

BUDAPEST FILM CHOIR

CHOIR CONDUCTOR:
Mr. Péter Drucker

ETHNIC SOLOISTS
CIMBALOM:
Kálmán Balogh

ETHNIC PERCUSSION:
András Dés

KAVAL, GADULKA:
András Monori

VOCALIST:
Bea Palya

VIOLIN SOLOIST:
Rhys Buchele

PRODUCTION ASSISTANTS:
Miss Maria Bakó
Miss Hajni Vedres

RECORDING ENGINEER:
Tim Jaquette

ORCHESTRATIONS BY:
Jonathan David Neal
Tim Doran

TECHNICAL ASSISTANTS:
Mr. Sándor Vesszös
Mr. Dénes Rédly

MUSIC PREPARATION & COPYING:
Tim Doran
Scott Douglas
Craig Ware
Miss Xénia Stollár

INTERPRETER:
Miss Csilla Zsilavecz

PRE-MIX, SOUND EFFECTS, ADR & RECORDING:
Easy Street Studios

SOUND ENGINEERS:
Greg Hill
Paul Miller

SUPERVISING SOUND EDITOR:
Bart Gavigan

MUSIC EDITORS:
Tim Jaquette
Jonathan David Neal

MIXED & DUBBED AT:
Citrus College, Glendora, CA

RE-RECORDING ENGINEER & FINAL MIX:
Tim Jaquette

ADR MIXER:
Michael Caudle

ADDITIONAL MUSIC:
Killer Tracks

SOUND MIX ASSISTANT:
Luke Krist

SCORE MIXER:
Tim Jaquette
David Rohl

BUDAPEST RE-RECORDING MIXER:
Tim Jaquette
Tom Hambleton CAS

ADITIONAL MUSIC BY
Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)

MUSICIANS:
Terry Elliot – Violin
Solveg Peterson – Cello
Sarah Bertsch – Violin

SONGS
“Immersed” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

“Magic Forest” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

“Ossuary 6 – Air” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

“Prelude and Action” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

“Intrepid” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

“Escape Velocity”
Composers: Erick DeVore [BMI], Timo Chen [BMI]
Publisher: Killer Tracks [BMI]
Courtesy of Killer Tracks

“Black Plague”
Composer: Anthony Edwin Phillips [PRS]
Publisher: Atmosphere Music Ltd PRS
Courtesy of Killer Tracks

ARCHIVAL FOOTAGE, PHOTOGRAPHY AND IMAGES PROVIDED BY:

Mahoney Media
Worthington Media Services
VideoBlocks.com
GettyImages.com
Shiloh Drone Footage – Greg Gulbrandsen
David Rohl
Keith Woods
Randel Price
Martin Severin

Ancient maps provided by:
Dr. Glen Fritz
Dr. Lennart Möller

Joseph Naveh Photo
by Gabi Laron – Institute of Archaeology, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem

QIsa example of damage col 12-13.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:1_QIsa_example_of_damage_col_12-13.jpg
Jb344tul at English Wikipedia [CC0]

1 QIsa example of cancellation marks.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:1_QIsa_example_of_cancellation_marks.jpg
Jb344tul at English Wikipedia [CC0]

Great Isaiah Scroll.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Great_Isaiah_Scroll.jpg
Photographs by Ardon Bar Hama, author of original document is unknown. [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Ahiram Sarcophagus 1.JPG
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ahiram_Sarcophagus_1.JPG
O.Mustafin [Public domain], from Wikimedia Commons

Sarcophagus with Phoenician writing 1.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sarcophagus_with_Phoenician_writing_1.jpg
Emna Mizouni [CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], from Wikimedia Commons

Sarcophagus with Phoenician writing 2.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sarcophagus_with_Phoenician_writing_2.jpg
Emna Mizouni [CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], from Wikimedia Commons

Sarcophagus with Phoenician writing 3.jpg
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sarcophagus_with_Phoenician_writing_3.jpg
Emna Mizouni [CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], from Wikimedia Commons

B/W photo Petrie c1897 & Pottery images: UC7627, UC7644, UC7646, UC44767 provided by University College London

Wadi el Hol Inscription 1 and 2 with line drawing of Inscription 1
Photographs by Bruce Zuckerman and Marilyn J. Lundberg West Semitic Research
Drawing by Marilyn J. Lundberg West Semitic Research
Encampment and John Darnell photography by John M. Melzian, West Semitic Research

ARCHIVAL RESEARCH BY:
Steven Law
Chad Greene
Timothy P. Mahoney

PRODUCTION EQUIPMENT:
Cinequipt, Inc.
Z Systems

BUSINESS MANAGEMENT & BOOKKEEPING:
Diane Walker

LEGAL & BUSINESS AFFAIRS:
Dan Satorius
Satorius Law Firm

PRODUCTION INSURANCE:
Associated Insurance Agents Inc.

All Bible references from the English Standard Version (ESV)

Special Thanks to:

PATTERNS OF EVIDENCE FRIENDS AND FAMILY:

Nicole, Isaac, Michael, Ingrid, Andrew, Karen, Molly & Jamie
Eliana, Milo, Cassin, Lola, William, Mila, Charles, Josie
Pete, Tamara and Zack
Jaimee, Kylee & Alex
Heidi, Hannah, Noah, Bethany, Rachel, Jonathan & Benjamin

Mark, Scott, Ruth, Dave, Colleen & Madan

TO LEARN MORE & PURCHASE THE FILM, VISIT:

www.patternsofevidence.com

This motion picture is protected under the laws of the United States, Canada and other countries. Any unauthorized exhibition, distribution or reproduction of this motion picture or any part thereof including the soundtrack, may result in severe civil and criminal penalties.